Pdf a kantian defense of abortion rights with respect for. For the sake of the argument a human embryo is a person. T does not think the conceptus a neutral way of referring to the fetus is a person from the moment of conception. David boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. The bojh argument was first popularized in 1971 by professor judith jarvis thomsons essay a defense of abortion from which boonin gets this books title, in which she compares the fetus to a hypothetical violinist with temporary kidney failure, who needs to connect his bloodstream to yours in order that your kidneys may maintain the. Critically examining a wide range of arguments that attempt to prove that every. Teenagers have also suffered the brunt of abortion restrictions. He believes, contrary to thomson, that both disconnecting from the violinist and aborting a fetus. In her groundbreaking 1971 article, a defense of abortion, judith jarvis thomson argues that even if one grants to the prolifer her most important premisethat the fetus is a personthe prolifers conclusion, the intrinsic wrongness of abortion, does not follow. Mar 18, 2016 in regards to the essay written by mrs. Building on the renewal of thomistic ethics encouraged by key moral encyclicals includi. The fundamental ethical objection traditionally advanced against these practices rests on the contention that human fetuses and infants have. Thompson in a defense of abortion, a position he initially states is. In chapter 3, i examine arguments that have been offered in defense of the claim that the fetus acquires this right at various points after its conception, and argue that, by the abortion critics own standards, the.
In this paper i will give a fairly detailed description of thomson main arguments for abortion. This suggests that abortion is morally permissible in cases of rape and also that the mere fact that the violinist is a person doesnt preclude the. By definition, then, maternal mortality must be equal than or greater to abortion mortality. A defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson 1971 most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. Bernard katz, a spokesman for the army surgeon general, saic dod policy based on executive order issued by former president nixon in 1972, permits abortion only where physical or mental health is threatened. The moral permissibility of abortion in her article, a defense of abortion, american moral philosopher and metaphysician judith jarvis thomson uses analogies to explain scenarios in which abortion is morally permissible, even when the fetus is granted personhood at conception.
A defense of abortion is a moral philosophy paper by judith jarvis thomson first published in. Judith jarvis thomson, a defense of abortion philpapers. Christianity, abortion is a thirdrail topic, untouchable in conversation or from the pulpit. But surely you have the right of selfdefense in that situation. So when thomson argues that it is permissible for a woman to abort a. Thomson, a defense of abortion, the following essay is an analysis of her arguments. Response to judith jarvis thomsons a defense for abortion judith jarvis thomson, in a defense of abortion, argues that even if we grant that fetuses have a fundamental right to life, in. Start studying judith jarvis thomson, a defense of abortion.
The question of abortion is one of constant contention and it has been the subject of virtually every form of argument known to man. A defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and public. Philosophers and the issue of abortion page 3 of 6 72700 the conservative position contends that from conception the fetus has full moral status. A critique of judith thomsons a defense of abortion essay cram. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson a defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson in the article a defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson argues that abortion is morally permissible even if the fetus is considered a person. Unlimited viewing of the articlechapter pdf and any associated supplements and figures. John noonan objects to the example of the unconscious violinist of thomsons model and offers a more realistic example. Most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the. In this article, thomson uses the phrase permissible to mean within ones moral rights. Critically examining a wide range of arguments that attempt to prove that every human fetus has a right to life, he shows that each of these arguments fails on its own terms. Thomsons strategy is to get us to think about cases that do not involve abortion, in order to force us to articulate our basic moral assumptions. Thomsons a defense of abortion a common argument against abortion.
Judith jarvis thomson a defense of abortion to print or download this file, click the link below. Thomson grants for the sake of argument the premise that a human embryo is a person she challenges the idea that one can argue effectively from this premise to the conclusion that all abortion is morally impermissible. Most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. Abortion mortality is a subset of maternal mortality. Thomson defense of abortion 3 march 2017 in this paper i will discuss the relevance of j. The famous violinist, people seeds and the chocolate example are three of a series of thought experiments in philosopher judith jarvis thomsons article a defence of abortion. Response to judith jarvis thomsons a defense for abortion judith jarvis thomson, in a defense of abortion, argues that even if we grant that fetuses have a fundamental right to life, in many cases the rights of the mother override the rights of a fetus. Essay about response to judith jarvis thomsons a defense for abortion. General interest a defense of abortion by david boonin skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Summary of judith jarvis thomsons, a defense of abortion. Wade 1973, this debate continues to intensify with no end in sight. As the title suggests the article aims to defend abortion at least in some cases.
The thesis of the book is that abortion is morally permissible, and it argues for this thesis by refuting all arguments for the claim that abortion isnotpermissible. Section 2 the antiabortionist aa could change their argument and say abortion is ok in cases of selfdefense but 3 rd parties cant perform them, only pregnant women can. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson essay. For a critical discussion of her argument, see chapter 3 of abortion and infanticide. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson in the article a defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson argues that abortion is morally permissible even if the fetus is considered a person. Debates over abortion are ordinarily thought to hinge on the status of the fetus. A defense of abortion critical exposition the goal of judith jarvis thomson in her defense of abortion is to sway the ideas of those who are against abortion by challenging the arguments they give for thinking so. The argument proceeds on the supposition that a fetus has a right to life and is a person. Introduction in this paper, i appeal to two aspects of immanuel kants philosophy his metaphysics and ethics in defense of abortion rights.
A defense of abortion by david boonin cambridge core. It justifies the claim that abortion, at least in typical cases, is morally permissible on terms that the critic of abortion can, indeed already does, accept. They have therefore kidnapped you, and last night the violinists circulatory system was plugged into yours, so that your kidneys can be used to extract poisons from his blood as well as your own. A critique of judith thomsons a defense of abortion essay. Stella browne, a pioneering feminist, campaigned for the liberalization of abortion law thomsons t imaginative examples and controversial conclusions have made a defense of abortion perhaps the most widely reprinted essay in all of contemporary philosophy. A defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson philosophy and public affairs,vol. The book concludes with a chapter that refutes the various nonrightsbased arguments that have been given mainly by nonphilosophers. This sample essay explores the book, a defense of abortion, to solidify and enhance the logic behind the prochoice argument.
To prove this point, thomson invents a thought experiment. A defense of abortion 1971 judith jarvis thomson do you agree that opposition to abortion relies on premise that fetus is a human being, a person, from moment of conception. In defense of abortion and infanticide springerlink. But a defense of abortion that succeeds on the critic of abortion s own methodological terms does none of these things. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson essay bartleby.
Judith jarvis thomson, a defense of abortion flashcards. Thomsons argument in her article, a defense of abortion, to that of pregnancy reduction and if there is any relevance, if there are exceptions or situations where that might change. A kantian defense of abortion rights with respect for intrauterine life. Introduction a common view in the line of argument on abortion arising from judith jarvis thomsons seminal piece is that abortion is permissible because the fetus has no right to be inside the woman. Maternal mortality includes abortion related deaths. A judithjarvisthomsoninspired argument on abortion stephen kershnar suny, fredonia 1. Thomsons arguments all stem from one question is abortion. While many denominations have some sort of statement on abortion. The step from a fetus is a person to abortion is morally wrong is usually taken for granted. A criticism of the selfownershipbased defense of abortion. Oxford judith jarvis thomson most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. Some of these cases are pretty silly, but that is because she wants us to think about the. A short guide on how to write a thesis at both the undergraduate and postgraduate levels.
Judith jarvis thomson a defense of abortion hcc learning web. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and figures for a period of 48 hours. Definitions of abortion mortality produced by the population research institute note. A defense of abortion by judith jarvis thomson 1971. Studydiscussion questions 1971 judith jarvis thomson. A defense of abortion is an article written by judith jarvis thomson that was published originally in 1971 to support the legalization of abortion. Granting for the sake of argument that the fetus has a right to life, thomson uses thought experiments to argue that the fetuss right to life does not trump the pregnant womans right to have jurisdiction over her body, and that induced abortion is therefore not.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. If its a person, then it is usually thought that the argument against abortion is sound, much as we saw with noonan. A critique of judith jarvis thomsons a defense of abortion, part i probably the most famous argument against the prolife position is judith jarvis thomsons violinist analogy, in which you are attached, against your will, to a famous unconscious violinist to prevent his dying from a kidney ailment. Does judith jarvis thomson really grant the prolife view. Does judith jarvis thomson really grant the prolife view of.
In a defense of abortion, she demonstrates that even if a fetus is a person, it may still be aborted. Definitions of abortion mortality population research institute. Judith jarvis thomson a defense of abortion most opposition to abortion relies on the premise that the fetus is a human being, a person, from the moment of conception. David boonin david boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. Whoever has a right to life should never be killed. Thomson a defense of abortion central question about abortion. Judith jarvis thomson is best known for a defense of abortion that con.
If we grant that a fetus has a right to life, does that make voluntary abortion immoral. Michael tooley abortion and infanticide this essay deals with the question of the morality of abortion and in fanticide. Many critics of abortion believe that one or another of these arguments are successful, and thus even if the defender of abortion succeeds in undermining the rightsbased argument, a defense of abortion that seeks to engage critics of abortion on their own terms must also address these arguments, and on terms that critics of abortion accept. By paying us to write a thesis paper a good thesis statement will accomplish the same thing. The thesis of the book is that abortion is morally permissible, and it argues for this thesis by refuting all arguments for the claim that abortion isnotpermissible, on grounds that the abortion critics themselves can accept. Hershenov is one such critic who argues that her challenge of the anti abortion premise is unsuccessful. Boonin surveys eight different argument strategies that purport to show. Personhood, property rights, and the permissibility of abortion. Feb 12, 2017 in this video, professor thorsby discusses judith jarvis thomsons essay a defense of abortion. In addition, i conclude that such an alteration requires marquis to adopt a position much like that taken by judith j. The premise is argued for, but, as i think, not well.
923 944 1520 793 1528 1426 838 1318 502 347 180 1538 1241 472 985 611 619 928 463 736 1324 749 1543 332 931 57 433 526 260 1292 309 1 38 149 541 107 1067 1154 1255 90